Ménilmontant to Montplaisir: A Study of Michel Chevalier and Saint-Simonism
Loading...
Date
2014-04-03
Authors
Ménard, Elton
Journal Title
Journal ISSN
Volume Title
Publisher
Mount Saint Vincent University
Abstract
Excerpt From Introduction:
"That the capitalist system functions badly is not a new phenomenon. In 1867, Karl Marx wrote in
the Preface to the first German edition of Capital that “Perseus wore a magic cap that the monsters he
hunted down might not see him. We draw the magic cap down over our eyes and ears as a make-believe
that there are no monsters.” Michel Chevalier (1806-1879) made a career out of hunting down monsters.
Both authors no doubt disagreed on who and what these were, however.3 This thesis is a study of
Chevalier the Saint-Simonian, and the ideology born from the works of Saint-Simon (1760-1825) known
as Saint-Simonism. Understood within the context of mounting criticism concerning the ideas and real
consequences inherent to industrial systems of production, a general theme exists throughout the paper,
and this is the idea that the capitalist system functions badly, that industry is disorganised. Discussion of
Saint-Simonism gravitates around this notion, with a particular emphasis on the treatment of capital and
social welfare as understood in the works of Chevalier. So two threads run through this thesis. The first
and most obvious is the discussion of his thoughts. The second, very much interwoven with the former, is
the interrogation of his involvement with the Saint-Simonian movement. The point is to consider him as
part of a social intellectual network that existed in the nineteenth century. The focus of this paper spans
from 1806 to 1879 and is purposefully kept broad to match his perspective. I hope that this approach is
useful to gain an appreciation of the various concepts born out of the long nineteenth century that
influenced his thoughts on European society and the globe, before attempting more in depth analyses of
specific periods of Chevalier's career; and to advance an alternate view regarding the length and breadth
of Saint-Simonism. My intention is to argue that Chevalier was a Saint-Simonian all his life; that it is
problematic to confine his involvement with the Saint-Simonian movement (and thus its impact) to the
dates 1825 to 1832; and that Saint-Simonism is more aptly characterised as an ideology spanning the lives
of Saint-Simon and Chevalier the Saint-Simonian".
Description
Undergraduate Honours Thesis written for HIST 4499.
Keywords
Michel Chevalier , Saint-Simonism , Saint Simon